Ok so when I started this post I did not initially see it to be a massive failure but more of a minor issue but still saw it as a significant problem that such an oversight could be happening on the night of Fox's most anticipated shows "Glee" is returning to TV. So as most people do I went to Google.com to do a search for Fox looking to find out if there was anyway I could watch "Glee" online but I did find it strange the such a large site would have index.html showing at their primary homepage. The more I dug into Fox.com the more issues I saw around a lack of understanding about SEO and well there is a lot of room for improvement as for consistency across just Fox.com not including the hundreds of other websites News Corp operates.Fox 404The Google search results show Fox.com/index.htm but when I clicked to visit the link it produces a 404 error page, this a both a major issue for Fox and a provides a very bad user experience for other fans using Google to get to Fox.com. I would expect a fair amount of traffic would flag a warning sign somewhere that a huge number of visitors were now viewing 404 error pages when coming from Google. The only upside is they have a nice simple 404 page that has a direct link back to Fox.com which works. There is Omniture tracking code on the Fox 404 error page so its fairly easy for their web analysts or web developers to notice the large spike in views of this page and that the source is a Google search referral, this would indicate failure by someone.It's not consistentIt seems that the use of index.html is not consistent across the site as you can see the 2nd result shown in the search results was the link to watch Fox full episodes on demand. It is indexed in Google as http://www.fox.com/fod/index.htm but unlike the homepage it doesn't resolve to a 404 error, this would indicate a failure by someone not a site wide policy change or update. If you are going to run a website it's always best practice to make a decision if you are going to use index.htm and stick with it. It causes problems for link builders, internal staff and other web developers within the Fox group who try to work out quickly which is the best URL to link to.Meta refreshes signal failure in seo
They are a very old technique and one that according to people on Google's spam team are typically wary of its uses as its been commonly misused in the past and is not a very search engine friendly technique. But Fox is using Meta Refresh to redirect users from http://www.fox.com/home.htm to http://www.fox.com/index.php which does not make sense to send them to a file instead of the root domain. Fox.com is not a small mum & pop business it should be able to get the basics around SEO right and not cut corners with a poor man's redirect "meta refresh".
Multiple links going to multiple Fox homepage URLs
Fox.com needs to consolidate its variations of the homepages as you can see below a number of the variations actually carry a decent amount of link juice that is likely going to waste. Once again if you are going to swap between index.php, home.htm and index.htm it will result in lost link juice and confuse everyone.
Best practice is consolidation of homepages
It is good practice to look using 301 redirects to consolidate any of the following variation of homepage that you have used or has inbound links to a your domain, it is possible that Fox.com will have links to almost all these variations of their homepage URLs.
http://www.fox.com/index.apsxNote: you need to test this to ensure that you don't create an endless redirection circle as has happened in my past projectsFox.com doesn't use canonical URLsThis is part of the issue around why these variations of the home page are being indexed and shown in the search result, it is another good practice to where possible use canonical URLs to signal to search engines where the primary or original source of content and not counted as duplicate content should be found by using the tag Rel="canonical"An example for this article would be <link rel="canonical" href="http://lostpr.es/2010/09/22/fox-com-fails-seo-2455236" />Who is linking to Fox.com/index.htm?Looking at the backlink profile of that particular page using SEOmoz Linkscape it seems that only part of the issue is within Fox's control. The issue of index.htm showing in the search result is more an external link issue with only 8.5% of the backlinks are internal or coming from other Fox.com subdomains. So even if Fox.com fixes their internal linking policies it seems its only part of the problem the easiest solution is to look at consolidation of those inbound links via 301 redirects.Fox.com is using 302sWhile it seems part of the issue is the non-use of 301s, the continuing use of meta-refreshes it also seems that for subdomains Fox.com has chosen to use the less than useful 302 redirects.So how can Fox.com fix it?Ok so here is how if you were Fox.com you could fix the issue since they are running the server on Apache/2.2.8 (Unix) PHP/5.2.5 with Suhosin-Patch they will likely have 2 easy options to organise the 301 redirects.
- .htaccess file
- Use cPanel