Tag Archive for seo

NRMA limits online insurance quotes

NRMA is one of the largest insurance companies in Australia, so you could assume that they would be proactive and flexible with their online quotes.  While looking at Travel Insurance for a recent conference trip, NRMA was one of the many companies I considered contacting to get a travel insurance quote. The screenshot below shows the reasons that I did not contact NRMA, my agency is based in the state of Queensland so I did not proceed with the quote process because Queensland was not an option or was most of Australia.

The screenshot also shows that the online quote is limited to Australian residents living NSW/ACT but if there is only two options why not just have a check box?

NRMA has fairly proactive in search optimisation campaigns, ranking #6 for the highly competitive search term “travel insurance” so why be so aggressive if they are going to limit their insurance quote platform to only 1 state and 1 territory?

The note that is partly covered by the drop down menu advises that the product is also not available to residents of Victoria, but it would be more useful to advise that the policy is only available to residents of ACT & NSW.  When you move the mouse over the text it appears to be a link but does not redirect you to page that explains what residents of Victoria should do, this would likely reduce the number of potential leads lost.

NRMA is not a small company and should have the resources to examine a better way to display the information or use geobased IP redirects to the relevant websites that deal with visitors who are not from NSW, ACT or Tasmania.  It is interesting that the footer of the webpage advises that they provide insurance in states including Tasmania but its not option in the insurance quote form.  So this would point to a failure in business process and a lack of understanding about online marketing and where their visitors come from.

If you read the fine print at the bottom of the website you can see the 3 links which advise visitors of the correct website to visit if they are not from ACT/NSW.  The information provides direct links for visitors from other states and territories such as Queensland, Western Australia and South Australia, but interestingly leaves out any mention of Victoria and the Northern Territory.  For any Australian company to be so vague and general in details about our states and territories does not demonstrate an understanding that a market exists outside of NSW.

Compared to a number of their competitors, the online quote form is not intuitive or easy to use and it is likely they are losing a number of leads because visitors leave and try and different website for a quote.  The important elements to understand is that you cannot limit what geographic regions visitors your website by choosing to only show in organic results for one city or state, if you want to do this look at Google AdWords Campaigns or Facebook Ads.  Organic results as a result of a successful link building campaign will drive traffic from a whole number of regions and there are ways to monetise that traffic that you cannot convert such as Victorian residents.

Velocity Credit Cards spam Google

This post follows on from an ongoing issue with affiliate networks being better than the actual publisher at search optimisation and at times spamming the search results with duplicate content.  Google has begun the process of applying gradual penalties and progressing to complete removal from affiliates from the search index. The problem is often affiliate networks are constantly launching new domains, subdomains off existing domains faster than Google is responding.

velocity-rewards-logoWith all the recent hype around VirginBlue’s Velocity Gold upgrade failure, there has been a significant uplift in search volume and it appears that some of these affiliate/automated results show the most to gain.

We can see from the results shown below that Velocity ranks #1 the Fairfax OMG owned #2 CreditCards.com.au result actually has a better call to action in its result and so would likely get a reasonable amount of clicks.  It is also noted that the NAB product information page does not actually feature in the first page of results and actually ranks #20 for the term “velocity gold”.

This poor ranking for one of their products shows that NAB needs to focus more on their online products as they are likely losing customers to affiliate networks who can often convert to sales better. As shown later in this post Banks.com.au are cross-promoting other Banks products against your product and also feature ads for competitors products such as the Qantas AMEX card.

velocity-gold-top-results

I have removed a Google news link and a link to a forum FlyerTalk for visual purposes.  But what about the remaining results and why do they all look similar? I have included the graphic of who provides the content and we can see the results are dominated by Mozo who appear to power the automated and duplicate content that is shown in the results. The final result is a Naked Communications run finance website likely operated on behalf of a client.

The Mozo-powered results are purely automated results with the only difference being the website name dynamically inserted into the page title and meta description.  The results look like spam and do not appear to provide a quality response to users.

velocity-gold

To show what I mean by automated/duplicate content for the Mozo-powered product I have included the pages shown above. The only slight difference between each of the pages is the website template being used with all using the same on site text content, on site images and even layout.  This is not quality content this is lazy automated results spamming the search results!

money-manager-credit-card-spam

brisbane-times-credit-card-spam

business-day-credit-card-spamwatoday-credit-card-spam

What about OMG Fairfax?

So lets compare the search results from OMG Fairfax and why they are similar websites why their results are better quality and more relevant.  Comparing Banks.com.au and CreditCards.com.au both while the content is similar I can clearly see while the text is similar they have ensured that the page titles and meta descriptions are unique but still relevant to the search result.

omg-credit-card-results

Meta Descriptions
The page description are included below to make it easier for you to visualise the slight differences in results.
CreditCards.com.au
NAB Velocity Gold Credit Card – review and compare Velocity Gold Credit Card features and apply for credit cards online.
Banks.com.au
The NAB Velocity Gold Credit Card – review the Velocity Gold Credit Card from NAB, compare features and apply for credit cards online.
Why is it not duplicate content?
So while both pages contain similar content why is CreditCards.com.au ranked higher than Banks.com.au? The CreditCard domain actually has around 20% more on site content related to the Velocity Gold Credit Card and also its domain is a more relevant for the content.
credit-cards-com-au
banks-com-au
Do you agree with my analysis of the search results and do you think the issue of affiliate/automated content is increasing or just getting better quality and harder to spot?

Google Keyword Significance Tool

Google-webmaster-toolsGoogle webmaster tools continues to evolve with a visual element added to its keyword data it provides to webmasters who have verified that they are the current owner of the site. There new webmaster feature mix some search optimisation benefits and an easier way to flag spam and hacked content.

Google Keyword Significance Tool

Google-Keyword-Significance-Tool

The new keyword feature is updated daily, and provides details on how often their Googlebot found a specific keyword.  To further add value to webmaster they now also provide a list of URLs that contain that specific keyword.
This replaces the previous numerical value that was listed within Webmaster tools.  The daily update allows for monitoring website rebuilds or identifying if your website has been hacked.  If you start to see your website appearing for unrelated search results you can use this feature to find if you have keywords hidden in your content.
google-webmaster-keywords-list

You can drill into these keywords and quickly identify which URLs contain them and eliminate any hacked content. We ensure all our clients are running Google webmaster tools to ensure they avoid any issues like Malware, Hidden content or Spam or check out this Webmaster’s Guide.

Event Cinemas fail to understand Search

bcc-cinemasAustralia’s largest cinema chains Birch Carroll & Coyle and Greater Union is in the process of being relaunched and redeveloped but have they started their online move too early or without an effective digital strategy.

We understand that the process of rebranding a company is very expensive and time consuming but we don’t believe that AHL successfully planned to get the best benefit from their online campaign with Event Cinemas.

event-cinemas

AHL is promoting Event Cinemas as a new concept in entertainment, that seeks to deliver the ultimate cinema experience. The Birch Carroll & Coyle and Greater Union cinemas are in the process of being redeveloped and relaunched as Event.  The other problem is that many of the Birch Carroll & Coyle and Greater Union cinemas will continue to operating throughout Australia.

It seems atleast online the Event Cinemas is now the sole online brand which seems to conflict with their offline marketing which still heavily promotes Birch Carroll & Coyle and Greater Union, which seeks to compete against Hoyts.

It appears that some improvements have been made in the last few weeks, but there is still a lot of quick wins for Event Cinemas.

How do they handle Event Cinemas visitors?

event-search

To prove that the online campaign has not being successful a branded search for Event Cinemas shows Greater Union in the #1 result.  The issue is that any visitors to GreaterUnion.com.au is redirected to EventCinemas so it is a wasted and unnecessary step for their visitors.

How do they handle Birch Carroll & Coyle visitors?

bcc-search
It appears that in the search results that Birch.com.au has completely disappeared but it is still being heavily advertised offline. This can potentially lead to confusion with consumers as they expect to see Birch.com.au in the results and Greater Union diverts to EventCinemas anyway.
You can see that yourmovies.com.au is taking some of that branded search traffic already.
Technical Analysis of their SEO
They appear to have started the process but have cut corners and failed to understand what they are doing, its benefit and why they are doing it. This is how they treat their visitors through redirection requests.
#1 Server Response: http://www.birch.com.au
HTTP Status Code: 301 Moved Permanently
Location: http://www.greaterunion.com.au/
Redirect Target: http://www.greaterunion.com.au/
#2 Server Response: http://www.greaterunion.com.au/
HTTP Status Code: 302 Object moved
Location: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
Redirect Target: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
#3 Server Response: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
HTTP Status Code: 302 Found
Location: /?ReDirect=True
Redirect Target: /?ReDirect=True
#4 Server Response: /?ReDirect=True
Wrong service type or malformed URL
How do they handle Greater Union visitors?

greater-union-search

Event Cinemas has started showing up in some branded search results for “greater union” but are they following best practice?
The move from the existing Greaterunion.com.au domain to the new Eventcinemas.com.au has not been done effectively and provides an opportunity for their competitors and other websites such as yourmovies.com.au to take their branded “greater union” traffic.
Technical Analysis of their SEO
They appear to have started the process but have cut corners and failed to understand what they are doing, its benefit and why they are doing it. This is how they treat their visitors through redirection requests.
#1 Server Response: http://www.greaterunion.com.au
HTTP Status Code: 302 Object moved
Location: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
Redirect Target: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
#2 Server Response: http://www.eventcinemas.com.au/Redirect/Home
HTTP Status Code: 302 Found
Location: /?ReDirect=True
Redirect Target: /?ReDirect=True
#3 Server Response: /?ReDirect=True
Wrong service type or malformed URL
facebook logo
Event Cinemas Social Media Campaign
They don’t even to take the extra steps for the Event Cinemas Facebook page, as there are a number of options available which have not been utilised. Some of the many Facebook username options that are available:
http://www.facebook.com/eventcinemas
http://www.facebook.com/cinemas
http://www.facebook.com/event.cinemas
So the key factors that are being ignore are refinements to their social media campaign and more effective search optimisation. Event Cinemas seems that they are being complacent online because of their domination of the industry, but their competitors can potentially steal their lead.
Some of the current competitors that can start to take market share away from Event cinemas include:

St George shows how to own Search Results

Today I noticed a new campaign running by St George and was interested to see how effective their online strategy would match and if it even existed. At The Lost Agency we often see large offline marketing campaigns are launched without an effective or even any complimentary digital campaign.

Since there are other banks who have similar products overseas, we thought we would review their product message and how at a basic level they performed in Google search result.

st-george-sense

St George performed well above my expectations around the product name controlling the first 6 results and also the single AdWords displayed.

Often product reviews or investment websites will show up high in the results but St George effectively controlled all the results shown above the fold.

st-george-sense-adwords

To test a very generic single product keyword “Sense”, did not show St George in the organic results but was visible as the single AdWords displayed.

st-george-saving-productSt George Bank’s new saving product “St George Sense” and this product is similar to a product Lloyds TSB released several months ago called “Save the Change” where users of its debit card can save easily.  In the US Bank of America has its own similar saving product “Keep the Change“.

The St George product is quite broad in its offering covering FreedomCard, ATM Cards, and BPay will be rounded, but limits purchases made in Australian dollars to merchants in Australia. This means that you won’t be able to get the double benefit of overseas shopping cashbacks offered by PayPal.

lloyds-tsb-save-the-changeLloyds TSB has had their product in the market longer and you would expect more control over the search results in Google.co.uk but this was not the case.

The first two results were controlled by Lloyds TSB but the 3rd result was for a Money Saving forum and the 4th result was for Microsoft Windows. This showed that they have not effectively controlled the organic rankings.

lloyds-tsbThe Lloyds TSB product appears to be marketed slightly better with a simple message of that they will round up the amount to the nearest pound and transfer the difference into your savings account.

The product name selected by Lloyds TSB also explains the product in simple terms that consumers understand and match the digital message.

The product names chosen by Lloyds TSB and Bank of America also seems to be better suited to being easily remembered by consumers.  To reduce the risk of becoming a generic term they have both registered trademarks of the product name.

bank-of-americaThe Bank of America product seeks to further improve and indirectly with its 5% matching of your savings transfers.  Offering 100% for the first 3 months with a cap on this bonus limited at $250 per year.  While these are great they make the product much more complicated to market and more confusing for consumers.

bank-of-america-keep-the-change

Bank of America’s results on Google.com showed that like Lloyds TSB they only control the first 2 results with random results showing that are not related or discuss Bank of America’s products. There is also a state specific landing page that means inbound links are split and their competitors could easily rank well for their product stealing their potential customers.

The problem is consumers can be easily confused so companies need to work to ensure they have more control over the search results when building new brands or products. Also since they are marketing and building a new product they should be following St George’s lead in reinforcing the message with Google AdWords.

From a product perspective Lloyds TSB wins for a simple message but St George seeks to win the most from its campaign with total control of the search results and we like that.

The St George product is quite broad in its offering covering FreedomCard, ATM Cards, and BPay will be rounded, but limits perchases made in Australian dollars to merchants in Australia.
The Lloyds TSB product appears to be marketed slightly better with a simple message of that they will round up the amount to the nearest pound and transfer the difference into your savings account.
The Bank of America product seeks to further improve and indirectly with its 5% matching of your savings transfers.  Offering 100% for the first 3 months with a cap on this bonus limited at $250 per year.  While these are great they make the product much more complicated to market and more confusing for consumers.
The product names chosen by Lloyds TSB and Bank of America also seems to be better suited to being easily remembered by consumers.  To reduce the risk of becoming a generic term they have both registered trademarks of the product name.
The problem is consumers can be easily confused so both companies need to work to ensure they have more control over the search results. Also since they are marketing and building a new product they should be following St George’s lead in reinforcing the message with Google AdWords.
From a product perspective Lloyds TSB wins for a simple message but St George seeks to win the most from its campaign with total control of the search results.

SEO Services Australia

It is a common request from clients but it is not often that a seo agency will actively list other competitors who they believe do a quality job. In the past 2 years I have met and spoken with a number of directors about their company beliefs, client roster and approach to client development. This list is subjective based on my hidden ranking factors and positions on this list may directly relate to their past or current projects.

The main point of this list is to help educate clients about who is available who actually have some intelligence behind their decisions and actually have some decent client results for highly competitive terms. The problem with seo is that it can be easy for boiler room style operations to hide behind smoke and mirrors, target non-competitive terms and not measure and report on results.

If you are going to select an seo firm, follow our advice and check a few key points:

  • Do they have a company blog?
  • Do have they have plenty of relevant articles on their blog
  • Do all the pages on their website work?
  • Is contact information upto date?
  • Do they contribute to the online community?
  • Have other seo firms actually heard of them?
  • Do they regularly attend/present at conferences?

If you are going to select an seo firm, follow our advice and avoid them if they offer:

  • guaranteed 1st placement on google
  • guarantee improved rankings before you tell them your keywords
  • only guarantee ranking improvements on Google.com.au “within Australia”
  • they offer services for $100/month
  • they have a blank blog with a “welcome to wordpress” message
  • they have to buy billboards to advertise
  • they advise blackhat is just misunderstood
  • they advise that “search engine optimisation” & “search engine marketing” is the same thing
  • dont track your traffic improvements
  • dont offer reporting of your results
  • they dont understand your business goals
  • they just focus on traffic as conversion are a secondary issue

Leading SEO Companies in Australia

While many agencies have offices in multiple locations, this is where they are based and their head office is located. If you are dealing with a local agency it can make the initial meeting process easier, but because the work is carried mostly via phone, email and web there is no reason you cannot deal with an interstate agency.

Brisbane SEO Agencies

The Lost Agency

Reload

 

Dejan

Sydney SEO Agencies

FirstRate

Wiliam

ewebmarketing

Amplify

Bruce Clay Australia

Melbourne SEO Agencies

Alkemi

Reseo

Exa

Newspapers dont get SEO

Read the original blog post from Paid Content, this is my response.

RE Quote: “If, however, you search Google for “eric schmidt newspapers”—we currently are the first link.”

Take this as an example of why newspapers don’t understand seo, what person would actually search for that phrase?

Just in case I checked and sorry no search traffic and HuffingtonPost is #1 & #2 So do you they actually understand what they are actually complaining about?

AP makes money by selling the story or through syndication agreements why would they want to fight their members for that traffic they are already being paid for???